In zombie movies, it’s easy to spot the danger: the slow, single-minded march of the undead, blindly following one another into chaos. But in the workplace, the threat of a herd mentality is far less obvious…but can be just as frightening!

When every idea gets a unanimous ‘yes’; when meetings feel more like echo chambers than collaborative spaces; and when dissent is quietly discouraged even in subtle ways, your culture may be at risk of slipping into conformity. And while alignment is often a sign of strong teams, unchecked agreeability can actually stifle creativity, innovation, and psychological safety in the long run.

So, how do we strike the balance? How do we build cultures that value both collaboration and courageous thinking?

Psychologically, humans are wired for belonging. In high-pressure environments, especially those recovering from change or crisis, the instinct to ‘stick with the group’ can feel like the safest move. No one wants to be the person who speaks up with a ‘what if’ when everyone else is already moving forward. And what can sometimes happen because of this is the unintentional reinforcement of this behaviour through celebrating harmony over healthy debate and hiring for culture fit rather than culture add.

And before long, employers have a workplace full of the walking agreeable – well-meaning, hard-working people who no longer feel that they can challenge the status quo.

Fostering a culture of independent thinking doesn’t mean encouraging rebellion for the sake of it. It means creating an environment where people feel safe to ask questions, challenge assumptions, and explore new paths, while still working towards shared goals. Here are some ways of doing this:

• Rethink How You Facilitate Meetings – instead of defaulting to open-floor discussions, consider rotating facilitators to ensure that a range of voices are being heard. Or, employers could incorporate a ‘devil’s advocate’ role in brainstorms to normalize constructive criticism.
• Build Psychological Safety Into the Culture – train leaders to respond to disagreement with curiosity rather not defensiveness. Celebrate moments where challenging the norm led to a better outcome, even if it was slightly uncomfortable at first, as this will help to normalize and encourage this behaviour!
• Diversify the Voices at the Table – hire for diversity of thought, background, and perspective. Then, make sure those voices are empowered to speak and are genuinely heard.
• Invite Feedback and Listen to It – are your employees regularly invited to give input on strategy, policy, or operations? Is their feedback acknowledged and acted upon? Make it clear that every voice matters – not just the loudest or most senior.
• Model It From the Top – when leadership demonstrates openness to being challenged, it sets the tone for the rest of the organization. Leaders admitting when they’re wrong (or even just unsure) can be one of the most powerful cultural shifts.

It’s tempting to equate agreement with progress, but real progress comes from the friction of ideas and the courage to question.

In a world that sometimes feels like it’s moving on autopilot, the organizations that thrive will be the ones who can think independently without losing their sense of connection. Because culture isn’t about creating clones, it’s about building a community where differences are not just accepted, but celebrated.

So let’s leave the herd behavior to the zombies!

If you would like to discuss how we can help build psychological safety into your workplace culture to encourage healthy dissent, please get in touch with us today!